2 Comments
Feb 23Liked by Melanie Kalmanson

So, being a simple man, I am confused. Is this third verdict valid or not?

Frankly, I think non-unanimous verdicts of DP are all invalid. But what do I know?

States that have unanimous verdict requirements certainly should keep them that way.

Expand full comment
author

Hi, Phil. For now, this verdict is valid because the 8-4 statute applied in this resentencing proceeding. Of course, there's not yet been a ruling on the merits of the 8-4 statute.

Expand full comment